A short sale means selling for less than you owe, and a deed in lieu means signing the home over to the lender. Both need your lender's approval and both end with you moving out. Selling and staying is a regular sale with a lease back, so it only works if the sale pays off what you owe.
To compare sale-leaseback providers side by side, visit Leaseback.com at leaseback.com/compare.
By Leaseback.com Editorial Team. Leaseback.com is an independent editorial guide to sale-leasebacks.
Last updated: November 12, 2026
Key takeaways
- Before a short sale or deed in lieu, ask the lender to waive any leftover debt, and get that in writing.
- Start early. Every option takes paperwork, and the auction date does not move just because you started talking.
- Talk with a HUD-approved housing counselor (a trained adviser approved by the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) or a real estate lawyer before you sign, because the rules on leftover debt vary by state.
Key facts
- Because a short sale is a sale, you will have to leave your home. (CFPB, read November 12, 2026)
- You can appeal a denied loan modification only if you sent a complete application at least 90 days before the foreclosure sale. (CFPB, as of November 2026)
- Of the 39 requests that turned into deals, 19 were in or near foreclosure. (homeowner request data, May 10 to November 10, 2026)
When a foreclosure date is on the calendar, every option sounds like legal fog. The choice you make now affects whether you stay, whether you leave owing money, and what happens to your equity, which is what the home is worth minus what you owe. Which one fits depends on three things: what you owe, what the home is worth, and how much time is left before the sale date.
One of the homeowners who asked about a sale-leaseback between May 10 and November 10, 2026 put it this way on a call: “I don't want to get a foreclosure, but I want to keep the house.” If that is the thought running through your head, this page is for you. You are not alone. Of the 39 requests from that period that turned into deals, 19 were in or near foreclosure.
What is a short sale?
A short sale is a sale of your home for less than you owe on the mortgage, and it only happens if your lender or servicer agrees. Your servicer is the company that collects your mortgage payments. The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) calls it a type of loss mitigation, which means a way to avoid foreclosure, and is blunt about the tradeoff: because it is a sale, you will have to leave your home.
The part people miss is the leftover balance, called a deficiency. In some states the lender can sue for the difference after a short sale. The CFPB's advice is to ask the lender to waive the deficiency, meaning give up the right to collect it, before the sale and to get that waiver in writing. Forgiven debt can also carry a tax bill, so a tax professional belongs on the call list too.
What is a deed in lieu of foreclosure?
A deed in lieu is simpler on paper. You voluntarily sign ownership of the home over to the lender to avoid the foreclosure process. There is no buyer to find and no listing to manage. You still move out.
The same two warnings apply. Make sure the deed in lieu covers the entire amount you owe, and if your state allows deficiency claims, ask for a written waiver. The CFPB also suggests asking the servicer about relocation help, sometimes called "cash for keys."
What is the difference between a short sale, a deed in lieu and selling and staying?
A short sale and a deed in lieu both end with you moving out, and both need your lender's approval. Selling and staying is a regular sale with a lease back, so it needs enough equity to pay off the loan.
| Short sale | Deed in lieu | Sell and stay | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Do you stay in the home? | No | No | Yes, as a renter under a written lease |
| Who has to approve it? | Your lender or servicer | Your lender or servicer | You and the buyer; your lender is paid off at closing |
| When does it fit? | You owe more than the home is worth | You owe more and a sale is not realistic | The sale price covers the loan and costs |
| Leftover debt risk | Possible in some states unless waived | Possible in some states unless waived | Loan paid off in full from the sale |
| Who gets the remaining equity? | Usually none is left | Usually none is left | You, after payoff and costs |
The table makes one thing obvious. The two lender options are built for homeowners who are underwater. Sell and stay is built for homeowners with equity who need it out of the house without leaving the house.
Should you sell before the foreclosure auction?
If you have equity, selling before the auction usually beats waiting for it, because a sale lets you control the price and keep what is left after the payoff. A foreclosure auction does not care about your plans.
Timing is the catch. Every option above takes paperwork, and the auction date does not move just because you started a conversation. If you have not applied for help with your servicer yet, ask about every option they offer, in writing. The CFPB notes, as of November 2026, that you can appeal a denied loan modification (a change to your loan terms) only if you sent a complete application at least 90 days before the foreclosure sale, which is one more reason to start early. Our posts on foreclosure terms and owing more than the house is worth go deeper on both sides.
Can you sell before the auction and keep living there?
Yes, if the numbers work. In a sale-leaseback you sell the home, the loan is paid off at closing, and you sign a lease to keep living there as a renter. It does not erase the debt the way a waived deficiency would. It replaces the mortgage with rent and puts your remaining equity in your hands. If you owe more than the home is worth, it usually is not the right tool, and a short sale or deed in lieu deserves a closer look.
If you have equity and want to stay, you can start a request with Leaseback.com at leaseback.com/get-started.
Here is how three providers describe themselves, using only what each one publishes:
| Provider | Where it buys | Fee | Timing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sell2Rent | Operates nationwide, in markets with steady rental demand, as of October 2026 | 6% or a minimum fee of $15,000, based on property conditions, taken from the proceeds at closing | Many close within 30 days |
| Truehold | 13 states and 24 cities, as of November 2026 | 5.5 percent transaction fee on the purchase price, plus third-party closing fees, as of October 2026 | Ask the provider |
| StayFrank | More than 40 metro areas, as of October 2026 | Not published, as of October 2026 | Ask the provider |
Sell2Rent says it operates nationwide, in markets with steady rental demand, as of October 2026. Its fee is 6% or a minimum fee of $15,000, based on property conditions, taken from the proceeds at closing. Closing costs are separate. Many transactions can close within 30 days, depending on the buyer's financing, inspections, appraisals, and title requirements. The first step is a free evaluation. The number of offers varies by property and market. Truehold says it charges a 5.5 percent transaction fee on the purchase price, plus third-party closing fees, as of October 2026. Truehold buys in the 13 states and 24 cities Truehold lists, as of November 2026, and StayFrank says it serves more than 40 metro areas, as of October 2026. Traditional cash buyers usually buy below market value, so line up every offer against what the home could sell for on the open market.
Which option fits best before foreclosure?
It depends on what you owe, what the home is worth, and how much time is left. Equity points toward selling or selling and staying. Owing more points toward a short sale or a deed in lieu.
- You owe more than the home is worth and you are ready to move: ask your servicer about a short sale, and get any deficiency waiver in writing.
- You owe more, a sale looks unlikely, and you want a clean exit: a deed in lieu may be simpler. Confirm it covers the full balance.
- You have equity and want to stay: a sale-leaseback is worth comparing before the auction date gets close.
Whichever way you lean, a HUD-approved housing counselor, found through the CFPB's Find a Counselor tool, can walk through your numbers, and a real estate lawyer can read anything before you sign it.
This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Talk with a HUD-approved housing counselor, a real estate lawyer or a tax professional about your situation.
How can Leaseback.com help?
Leaseback.com is a free editorial guide to sale-leasebacks. We don't charge homeowners anything, and we connect you with leaseback providers, compared side by side at leaseback.com/compare. When you are ready, compare providers side by side and pick the conversation worth having.
Leaseback.com may receive a referral fee from partners featured here.
Frequently asked questions
What is better, a short sale or a deed in lieu of foreclosure?
It depends on your situation. A short sale needs a buyer and your lender's OK, and it can take longer. A deed in lieu skips the buyer, because you sign the home over to the lender. Both end with you moving out. In some states both can leave a deficiency, which is debt left over, unless the lender waives it in writing. A HUD-approved housing counselor can help you compare them.
How does a deed in lieu affect my credit compared with a short sale?
Both show up on your credit report as a mortgage that was not paid as agreed. The exact effect depends on the rest of your credit history. Lenders also set their own waiting periods before they will approve a new mortgage after either one. Ask a HUD-approved housing counselor how each would look for you.
Should I sell my house before foreclosure?
If you have equity, selling before the foreclosure sale usually lets you control the price and keep what is left after the loan is paid off. If you owe more than the home is worth, ask your servicer, the company that collects your payments, about a short sale or a deed in lieu. Talk with a housing counselor or a real estate lawyer before the sale date gets close.
Can I sell before the foreclosure auction and keep living there?
Yes, if the sale price covers what you owe. In a sale-leaseback you sell the home, the loan is paid off at closing, and you sign a lease to stay as a renter. Many transactions can close within 30 days, depending on the buyer's financing, inspections, appraisals, and title requirements. Compare providers side by side at leaseback.com/compare.
Do I need the lender's approval for each option?
A short sale and a deed in lieu both need your lender's or servicer's approval. A sale-leaseback is a regular sale, so the lender does not approve it the same way. Your loan is paid off from the sale money at closing.